Cheap Vs. Expensive Car Seats – What Parents Need to Know

This article has been updated on

Everyone wants what’s safest and best for their child. It’s our job to keep them safe, and it’s a job that can make us all feel just a little bit crazy. Unlike a stroller or a swing, a car seat really is a safety device because, without a good car seat that’s properly installed, we know that children are tangibly more likely to get seriously injured or worse in the event of a crash.

The question is this: is your child as safe in a $100 car seat as they are in a $700 car seat? The answer is a resounding YES. Car seats are heavily regulated and must pass serious safety standards. ALL car seats must pass the same standards!

Car Seat Installation is Key

The biggest threat to your child’s safety in the car isn’t whether their car seat is expensive or not, it’s whether their car seat is properly installed or not. Various agencies report different findings, but somewhere between 70 and 90 percent of car seats are not installed properly.

There’s no evidence that more expensive seats protect children any better during a crash, but there’s plenty of evidence that a properly installed seat will protect your child. In fact, the risk of serious injury for a child involved in a crash drops to 1% if the car seat is properly installed! Now that’s some serious peace of mind.

Check out the CDC for more information on proper installation and for tons of information about choosing the right car seat.

There are lots of places that you can go to get your child’s car seat checked to make sure that it’s installed properly. Many stores that sell car seats have safety officers who can check the installation through the easiest place to go is probably your local fire station. It cannot be said enough – proper installation is essential!

What IS the Difference between Cheap and Expensive Car Seats?

If the difference in a cheap car seat and an expensive car seat isn’t the safety – then what is it? It’s all of the accessories and extras! While all car seats will offer your child right around the same level of protection in a crash, they won’t all offer your child the highest level of comfort or fun, or the same level of style for you.

In the spirit of understanding those differences, let’s have a look at car seats using the following parameters:

  • Comfort
  • Style
  • Ease
  • Accessories

Check out the following charts for some real evaluations of car seats through these criteria, separated by age and type of car seat. Sometimes the extras really are worth the price tag!

Infant Car Seats

Evenflo Nurture Infant Car Seat

  • Comfort – Minimal padding
  • Style – Simple, streamlined
  • Ease – A bit awkward for parents to carry
  • Accessories – None
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Graco SnugRide 30 Classic Connect

  • Comfort – Extra padding, rolled edges
  • Style – Cozy, gender neutral
  • Ease – Lightweight, comfort handle
  • Accessories – None
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Chicco Key Fit Zip Infant Car Seat

  • Comfort – Extra absorbing foam
  • Style – Duo colored, sleek
  • Ease – Narrow, easy to carry
  • Accessories – Zip off canopy, visor and boot
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Orbit Baby G3 Infant Car Seat

  • Comfort – Energy absorbing foam
  • Style – Interesting, modern, unusual
  • Ease – Soft carry handle, swivel base for side loading
  • Accessories – Full length shade
Read Verified Customer Reviews

High Back Booster Seats

Evenflo Big Kid AMP Booster Car Seat

  • Comfort – Minimal padding
  • Style – Simple, streamlined
  • Ease – Machine washable pad
  • Accessories – 2 cup holders
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Evenflo Maestro Booster Car Seat

  • Comfort – Generous padding
  • Style – 4 color options
  • Ease – 5 point harness and belt positioner
  • Accessories – Double cup holders
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Graco Nautilus 3-in-1 Car Seat

  • Comfort – Energy absorbing foam
  • Style – Duo colored, sleek
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Britax Frontier G1.1 Clicktight

  • Comfort – 9 position harness, reclines!
  • Style – 8 color varieties
  • Ease – Simple installation,
  • Accessories – Two cup holders, lots of optional add ons like seat protectors.
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Low Back Booster Seats

Disney Backless Booster Car Seat

  • Comfort – Minimal padding
  • Style – Disney!
  • Ease – Simple installation
  • Accessories – Retractable cupholders

[/span4][span4]

Read Verified Customer Reviews

Evenflo Big Kid Elite

  • Comfort – Extra padding
  • Style – Cool, creative, stylish
  • Ease – Easy to clean
  • Accessories – Two cupholders
Read Verified Customer Reviews

Clek Ozzi Backless Booster Seat

  • Comfort – High armrests, extra padding
  • Style – Blends in with car interior
  • Ease – Microfiber for comfort and cleaning
  • Accessories – Removable cover
Read Verified Customer Reviews

One Last Reminder

Again, please keep in mind that the most important part of this whole process is making sure that your child’s car seat is properly installed. Whatever brand or model you choose, take your car to an expert to make sure that your child’s car seat is properly installed. It might save your child’s life in the event of a crash.

EVA Baby Gear